Wednesday, January 6, 2010
You're under no compulsion but
Monday, January 4, 2010
Never born
Okay now you are ready to find out how much of a problem this is in Australia. Before I tell you, you need to understand about how people of all ages die in Australia and in what numbers. The only reputable figure for numbers of abortions in Australia is for the 2003-2004 financial year. So I looked at the deaths recorded by the ABS for the 2004 calender year (abortion is not included in these statistics).
In 2004 the total number of people who died in Australia was 132, 508. The ABS found that the leading cause of death was 'malignant neoplasms', which killed 37, 989 people. The number of children and adults who were murdered was 164.
Meanwhile on the 31st January 2005 Senator Boswell asked the Minister representing the Minister for Health and Aging a number of questions about abortion figures in Australia. These questions were answered by the Minister, Senator Patterson, on the 10th May 2005. Abortion statistics aren't recorded anywhere centrally, so the Minister had to compile the statistics from a number of sources (eg Medicare rebates). The figure he came up with for all of Australia (in roughly the same time period as the ABS statistics I quoted above) was appoximately 90, 000 abortions. He then forwarded his findings to each state health minister and they all agreed with this figure (except the NSW minister who didn't reply in time).
This means that for approximately the same time period, deaths due to abortion accounted for more than double the highest recorded number of deaths due to any other single cause. If they were to be included in the ABS figures, the 90, 000 deaths because of abortion would add a further 68% to the total number of people who died in Australia that year. This figure of 90, 000 far outshadows the 164 people that the ABS recorded as murdered.
So you see why I think this is one of the most major issues to face the church today. And why I think that history will be even more confounded and disgusted by our inaction than we are at those German Christians who stood by while their Jewish neighbours disappeared. But I also think this is a highly complex and clearly sensitive issue, and that ignorance and tragically misplaced good intention are part of the mix. So I'm in no way advocating a heavy-handed approach. In fact, I'm inclined to think that only those who are particularly gifted should do things like lobby. But that doesn't mean there's nothing for the rest of us to do. We can pray hard. We can celebrate pregnancies and families. We can care for single Mums and families in crisis. And we can share God's forgiveness and comfort with women who've had abortions.
Women's ordination
Anyhow, the women who contributed to this book would most certainly not agree with me. Some because they've interpreted the Bible differently to me. Others, however, because they've take a more pragmatic, felt approach. The editor, Barbara Field starts by simply observing that:
Until fifteen years ago, women were non-existent in the official ministry of the Anglican Church. Public and liturgical functions were carried out by men. The
administering and governing of the Church were done by men. There were no women in the three orders of minstry - deacon, priest and bishop. The people in the sanctuary were men. The people in the procession were men, except for members of the choir where women were allowed because there were not enough men who would join. The whole public face of the Church was, and indeed mostly still is, male. The chief contradiction to this up-front male scene was that most of the congregation were women, and most of the people at prayer meetings and Bible studies were women.2
She simply assumes that lack of leadership equals lack of respect and value. This assumption echoes throughout the book and results in talented, caring women experiencing great pain and suffering. As they see it, God has given them gifts to lead his people that they are unable to exercise. This is something that they feel very deeply. And it is because of this that they put themselves forward - not because they're ball-breaking feminists, but because they believe they it is what God is calling them to do. They accept the leadership positions and responsibilities that their denomination or area is prepared to give them, and humbly, patiently wait for that time when they will be given more.
I'm really glad I read the book. It helped me understand why people are so ardent about women needing to be ordained. But it made me sad that (as I understand it) these women have too quickly bought into our society's view that your worth is measured by your function. This belief has all manner of ugly repercussions - like for the elderly and people with disabilities. But God sees things differently. Everywhere in Scripture women are respected, affirmed and told their worth, and men are commanded to treat their women well. But Scripture also presents two different sexes, each with a different, complementary role. And fulfillment of gifts can be found within that role.
The book ends with some very wise words from Beatrice Pate:
Above all, we must have confidence in God. We are members of his Church, visible and invisible. Victory is his; it was won through the Cross. Each of us called to follow him will share that victory with him. How dare we suggest that only those who view the world in a particular way are being true to him - he had called us all, with all our differences and in spite of our wilful sinfulness. We must treat each other as brothers and sisters, with love and acceptance. This applies to a person totally opposed to the ordination of women when approaching a women who is ordained. It applies to the proponent of ordination of women when faced with one who rejects even the possibility that ordination could 'work' on a women . . . . The model I am proposing calls for us to act with love towards each other, to begin to grow to maturity in him in whom we will all one day come to completion, and to stop squabbling like two-year-olds deprived of their toys. What I suggest is easy to reject. Those opposed to the ordination, believing right is on their side, feel obliged to fight the ordination question as a matter of fundamental importance. Similarly, those in favour of the ordination of women can easily beliee that as a part of a persecuted 'minority' they must stridently demand their 'rights'.
. . . . But this does not let us ignore the call to continue striving in the path of love.3
1 B Field (ed), Fit For This Office: Women and Ordination (Melbourne: Collins Dove, 1989)
2 Field, "Introduction," 1.
3 Pate, "Rights or Reconciliation: A Personal Statement," 121.
Intimidation
In a lot of ways I love living in Sydney, but I've had trouble feeling confident here. Getting back after Christmas I realised that it's hard to be yourself in a city. You step out the door and not only are you not going to see anyone you know, maybe they'll attack you or snatch your bag or just be drunk or wierd. So you become this closed-off person while you're out. And then even when you get where you're going, you don't know these people. You didn't grow up with them around - they're all new and there's a lot of them.
I'm getting better at it now. I'm learning that people are people and relationships are relationships whatever the setting, and that I mustn't let the environment throw me off course.
Do any of you, my city-born readers, have tips for making your way in the big smoke?
An artist
You must master and attend to foundational skills.
You must have the humility to follow proven rules.
You must break the rules if you need to.
You must follow your heart and never let anyone stop you.
Motherhood statements and bells at eucharist
- think through what's going on and what's being said (eg what do the prayers for the dead say about what was achieved on the cross?),
- have the guts to call heresy masquarading as truth by its proper name,
- have the humility to rejoice in your unlikely (and even undesirable) brothers and sisters in Christ.